Rocket Writes a Story
written and illustrated by Tad Hills
published by Schwartz & Wade, 2012
My thoughts as a writer:
I liked the way the story brought out some of the realities
of the writing process, but I found the story itself a little slow paced and
wondered whether it would hold a child’s interest. A little bit of mystery
about a nest in a tree helped to carry the story forward and I could study how
the illustrations and words worked together to make this effective. Overall,
this book seemed best suited for educational
purposes, rather than for entertainment.
This would be a good book to support a
discussion of the process of writing. I appreciated the way the story showed how much
hard work goes into writing and how a story can continue to change as the writer thinks of new ideas or re-reads what is written.
This story also showed how we can be inspired by nature, which fits with
the Reggio Emilia philosophy of teaching. However, the story itself was a
little quiet for me and could have benefited from a bit more action or
conflict. This book would be suitable for grades K-2, but in a kindergarten
class, I might break up the reading into a couple of sessions, since it’s long for a picture book.
When I was teaching third grade I would have loved a book like this to help teach writing skills.
ReplyDeleteI saw this book and thought it looked cute. I enjoyed reading your thoughts. It just goes to show you that if you are an established author or have a great character, your book can be published even if it doesn't fit with what is selling today. (i.e. action packed and short)
ReplyDeleteYour "Learning from Picture Books" is a great idea, Andrea. I'll look forward to those posts. I also write PBs when I'm not working on MG novels.
ReplyDeleteI've read this charming picture book and I have to agree it's a little slow and quiet and I've wondered if kids would like it.
Would this have been published if it was his first book? Since he's the successful author/illustrator of those Duck and Goose books, maybe he gets a pass.